What’s the best NHL team you can build for 2025-26 using today’s contracts?

Back in 2019, my readers needed me to build the best doable cap-compliant roster I might assemble using present contracts. That’s not an particularly distinctive concept, and it isn’t even all that difficult if you load up on entry-level contracts. So we added a twist: We have been attempting to look three years into the future, to the 2021-22 season. That meant we needed to depend on long-term contracts, with no entry-level offers or different short-term bargains.

You can discover that put up right here, and I ultimately revisited it to see the way it turned out. In brief: I scored huge with guys like Nathan MacKinnon, Elias Lindholm and Aleksander Barkov. I additionally whiffed on John Gibson over Connor Hellbuyck, and in some way Paul Byron ended up on the team.

All in all, I did OK. But I would like one other shot. So at the moment, I’m giving myself one, as we revisit the idea in an up to date try to build for the future. We do not know what the cap might be in 2025-26, and the pandemic period made it more durable to guess. But we do have Elliotte Friedman’s report from just a few months in the past that the league was projecting $92 million, so we’ll go along with that.

As a refresher, listed below are the floor guidelines:

• We’re centered on the 2025-26 season right here, which means each contract we decide has to stretch at the least that far. Extensions which might be signed however have not kicked in but are advantageous, however in any other case, we can’t use anybody whose present contract expires earlier than then. Boston followers hold telling me that pending UFA David Pastrnak will take one other hometown low cost, and I’d by no means doubt them, however till that occurs he can’t be on our roster.

• We need the best team doable in 2025-26, not at the moment, which means we’re projecting forward and age might be an vital issue.

• We do not care about actual {dollars}, solely cap hit.

• We want 12 forwards, six defensemen and two goalies. We needn’t have any spares, though we can add some at the finish if we now have room, which we completely won’t. We’ll attempt to steadiness facilities and wingers and defensemen taking part in on their correct aspect, however we can’t obsess over it. After all, these guys have three years to regulate to new positions if we want them to.

• We’re assuming everybody might be wholesome in three years, with the exception of fellows like Shea Weber who’re already LTIR-retired.

There are 171 gamers with offers that run by 2026, starting from MacKinnon’s $12.6 million cap hit to Paul Cotter’s $775,000. One of these gamers is healthier than the different. One can also be extra more likely to find yourself on our roster, however we’ll get to that.

Let’s get began, constructing from the internet out as all good groups do.


This was the hardest place final time, and it isn’t a lot simpler this time round. There are solely 14 goalies in the league with offers that run by 2025-26, and one among them is Carey Price. Among the others, it is a exhausting go on names like Elvis Merzlikins, Philipp Grubauer, Jack Campbell and Sergei Bobrovsky. I will not fall for Gibson this time. And at a lofty $9.5 million, I do not assume we’ll have the ability to afford Andrei Vasilevskiy.

That leaves seven candidates for two spots, and this is the place issues look a bit of brighter than they did just a few years in the past. This time, there are literally a handful of moderately priced choices, together with obvious All-Star Stuart Skinner at $2.6 million and Pyotr Kochetkov at simply $2 million. There are additionally two stable younger choices in Spencer Knight at $4.5 million and Thatcher Demko at $5 million.

A number of months in the past, this is able to have felt like a slam dunk: Demko could be our starter. But he is been terrible this yr, which makes me a bit of nervous. Knight hasn’t been significantly better, however at 24 in 2025-26 he ought to simply be coming into his prime. Of course, he could have already got turned out to be a bust. I’m unsure I belief Skinner, and Kochetkov is in the AHL proper now and might be one more pretend Hurricanes goalie that they bail on earlier than the remainder of us determine it out.

Even with all these cheap doubts, I can’t speak myself right into a costlier possibility like Jordan Binnington or 35-year-old Jacob Markstrom. So I’ll roll the cube on a cheap-ish combo that may release cash elsewhere. Give me Thatcher Demko and Pyotr Kochetkov as my duo.

Cap house spent thus far: A tidy $7 million on two gamers, leaving us with $85 million for our 18 skaters, a median of $4.7 million every.


There are 59 gamers to select from right here, at the least in principle. I’m not going anyplace close to Erik Karlsson or Drew Doughty of their age-35 seasons, for instance, and I’m definitely not paying north of $9 million for Darnell Nurse or Seth Jones. I did at the least take into consideration spending the $9.5 million on a Charlie McAvoy or Adam Fox, and Miro Heiskanen may be very tempting at $8.45 million, however I simply will not have the ability to afford to inventory my blue line with huge names.

Instead, I’ll splurge on two big-ticket objects, beginning with a 26-year-old Cale Makar, who might need three Norris Trophies by then and can nonetheless have a yr left on one among the most team-friendly contracts in the league. I’ll pair him with one other younger star in his prime who needs to be a pleasant worth Quinn Hugheswho’ll value us $7.85 million.

Quinn Hughes. (Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images)

That’s a pleasant begin, however we’re spending nearly twice our $4.7 million common on our prime pair which suggests we’ll should go low-cost the remainder of the approach. Of our 59 blue-line choices, solely seven carry a cap hit below $4 million, so this can get away from us rapidly if we do not discover just a few severe bargains. In reality, I’d argue that after Makar and Hughes are off the board, the subsequent most evident decide on the complete record could be Matt Benning, a superbly stable third-pairing possibility who’ll carry a rock-bottom price ticket of simply $1.25 million in the final yr of an extension he signed in July. The different identify that jumps out right here is Calgary’s Rasmus Anderssonwhose $4.55 cap hit is a discount proper now, not to mention in three years when he’ll nonetheless solely be 28 on opening evening.

I would like a lefty to play with Andersson, and there are two names I’m contemplating: Josh Morrissey and Hampus Lindholm. Both are having unexpectedly nice seasons this yr, which does not assure that they’re going to nonetheless be at that degree in three years. Both have cap hits that begin with a six, and each might be on the flawed aspect of 30 by the time our team takes the ice. I went backwards and forwards a bit, however I’ll go along with Josh Morrissey at $6.3 million since he is each youthful and cheaper.

I’ve one spot left on the third pair, and I’ll give it to a different low-cost possibility: Brett Kulak, who’ll be in the final yr of a $2.75 million deal, making him the third-cheapest possibility on the board. He’ll be 33 in 2025-26, so there isn’t any assure he is even nonetheless in the league. But he is been completely advantageous in Edmonton, so I’ll threat him over somebody like Brandon Carlo or Josh Manson to avoid wasting additional house to spend on a ahead.

Cap house spent thus far: We simply spent $31.65 million on our blue line, a median of $5.275 per participant. That’s above what we might budgeted, however that is the hardest place to fill in this type of train, so I feel we’ll be OK. Combined with our $7 million goaltending, we have spent $38.65 million thus far, leaving us with $53.35 million for 12 forwards, a median of simply over $4.44 million every.


There are 98 forwards who’re signed by our 2025-26 season, most of whom we wish no a part of. But there is definitely some worth accessible, even amongst top-line expertise. We’ll begin there, constructing an elite first line after which hoping we now have sufficient left over to fill out the others.

We’ll begin with our first-line middle: Jack Hughes, a no brainer at $8 million. He’s having the breakout we have been ready for, and there is a respectable likelihood he might have a Hart Trophy to his identify three years from now. He’ll even be simply 24 years previous, and can in some way nonetheless have 4 full seasons left on his deal. This could be the contract that takes over from MacKinnon as the best discount in the whole league.

Our prime left winger might be one other apparent alternative Jason Robertson, who’ll be in the closing yr of an extension that carries a cap hit of $7.75 million. We can in all probability afford another big-ish ticket, and there are just a few choices that ought to seem like worth offers in just a few years. Both Brady Tkachuk and Tim Stützle come to thoughts after making long-term commitments in Ottawa at simply north of $8 million. Kyle Connor is simply above $7 million. I thought of Nico Hischier and Andrei Svechnikov. But in the finish, I simply can’t resist: Give me Tage Thompsonwho needs to be valued at $7.14 million even when he can’t keep this yr’s monster tempo.

That’s a enjoyable first line, but in addition a dear one, so it is time to go discount looking. I’ll begin with Kirby Dach, who’ll are available at simply $3.36 million. When he signed that extension, I mentioned there was no approach he’d be value that by the finish, however I wasn’t positive if it might be approach too excessive or approach too low. He’s halfway by his first yr in Montreal and trending in the direction of the latter, so he is on our team. I’ll spherical out an all-Atlantic second line with Alex Tuch at $4.75 million and Drake Batherson at $4.975 million.

I’ve bought to be even cheaper on the third line, so I’ll begin with Nick Paul. I nonetheless do not perceive why the Lightning signed him a contract that does not expire till the solar explodes, but it surely works for our functions as a result of his cap hit is barely $3.15 million. I’ll keep round that vary Boone Jenner, who’ll are available at $3.75 million. And these two worth offers imply I can splurge only a bit on my closing top-nine ahead, so give me Arthur Lehkonen at $4.5 million.

I’m all the way down to about $6 million to spend on my whole third line, so my choices are restricted. I’ll begin by spending half of that on Nicolas Roy, who’ll value us $3 million. On one wing, whereas I do not like the four-year contract that my Leafs dedicated to him, I’ll use it to take Calle Järnkrok at $2.1 million. And our final ahead might be the man you at all times knew we might wind up with: Paul Cotter and his $750,000 deal, which simply barely will get us below the wire.

Cap house spent thus far: Our ahead group ended up costing us $53.26 million. That brings our complete to only a shade over $91.9 million, simply barely below our $92 million higher restrict.

Here’s what our closing roster finally ends up trying like.

Forward Forward Forward

Jason Robertson

Jack Hughes

Tage Thompson

Alex Tuch

Kirby Dach

Drake Batherson

Boone Jenner

Nick Paul

Arthur Lehkonen

Paul Cotter

Nicolas Roy

Calle Jarnkrok

Defense Defense Goalies

Cale Makar

Quinn Hughes

Thatcher Demko

Rasmus Andersson

Josh Morrissey

Pyotr Kochetkov

Matt Benning

Brett Kulak

It’s not dangerous. It’s additionally not some type of unstoppable All-Star team, however then that is sort of the level in a cap league. We’ve bought a completely dominant first line, which we might cut up as much as steadiness the scoring, and a few good depth with upside. We’ve bought a Norris Trophy winner main a wonderful prime pairing. In objective we now have … properly, we now have a Norris Trophy winner on the prime pairing, so we’ll determine it out.

Three years from now this team might be moderately younger, with many key gamers simply coming into their prime. It may also have most of the roster coming into their contract yr, so they need to be motivated. And if anybody will get damage, we have nonetheless bought a handful of loonies and toonies to spend on depth. This cap-era roster-building stuff is more durable than it seems to be, however I’m OK with how this turned out.

Can you do higher? Want to swap anybody in or out? Take your shot in the feedback.

(Top photograph of Cale Makar: Isaiah J. Downing / USA Today)


Leave a Comment