There’s little doubt at this level relating to the standard of Sifu. It’s a legitimately nice game that blends collectively lots of the best elements of fighting video games and beat ’em ups, however does that make it a fighter?
This is the query presently hitting the gaming neighborhood as soon as it was revealed this week that Sifu was nominated for the best fighting game at The Game Awards 2022, and ideas on the matter are understandably in all places to say the least.
Looking purely at the game’s mechanics, Sifu does share a lot of his DNA with fighters in his strike, throw, parry rock paper scissors fight in addition to many strategies acquainted to fighting game followers.
All of that’s tremendous cool and simple to understand, however that does not inherently make the SloClap title match properly into the style.
The important concern individuals are hung up on is that Sifu is a single-player solely game. There aren’t any Versus or on-line multiplayer modes at all.
According to The Game Awards’ personal class description, the fighter nominees are primarily based round “the best game designed primarily round head-to-head fight.”
There is not any “head-to-head” fight in Sifu until you rely fighting the AI enemies and executives, however TGA did write “primarily” as an alternative of one thing like solely.
SIFU was nominated for best FIGHTING GAME!? Might be a scorching take…however it’s not. A unbelievable game deserving of presumably the best Action Game, however it did not even have a VS mode.
The argument of what makes a FG has been occurring because the 90s, however at least all of them are 2 gamers. pic.twitter.com/P1JGo8uDOL
— Maximilian Dood (@maximilian_) November 14, 2022
Single-player targeted fighting video games are uncommon however have existed for a long time like Capcom’s ill-fated Red Earth — though even these titles sometimes nonetheless embody a Versus mode.
To see if there was any precedent for Sifu’s categorization, we appeared by all the best fighting game nominees since they have been first included within the awards round a decade in the past.
There are some debatable nominees like Nidhogg 2, WWE All Stars and a handful of area fighters, however every considered one of them did characteristic a multiplayer part.
So that appears to go away Sifu because the one and solely title you possibly can’t play in opposition to one other particular person.
Sifu is a nice game, however being right here as soon as once more jogs my memory that the Fighting Game class at the Game Awards is at all times voted on by individuals who do not play a lot of fighting video games. https://t.co/n8pTcLhOR0
— Aaron – Thorgi’s Arcade (@ThorgisArcade) November 14, 2022
We have not discovered something to recommend Sifu considers itself a fighting game, because it’s usually labeled as an motion beat ’em up.
This could also be simply an arbitrary nomination for an awards present to fill out a yr with few new releases though some fear / marvel if the choice muddies the waters of what the broader gaming neighborhood goes to think about a fighting game now.
They at all times disrespected the fighting game style at the awards. Sifu although 😂😂😂 lmfaooooooo
— Panda Kizzie Kay (@Kizzie_Kay) November 14, 2022
Outside of Sifu’s give attention to martial arts, the game’s construction and design shares rather more in widespread with a character motion game like Devil May Cry or Bayonetta than it does Street Fighter or Tekken.
It would not seem like a state of affairs the place TGA needed to applaud Sifu for his achievements however lacked a totally different spot for it as a result of they’re additionally nominated for best motion game this yr too.
Up in opposition to some robust competitors in MultiVersus, The King of Fighters 15, DNF Duel and JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure: All Star Battle R, Sifu appears unlikely to stroll away with the trophy — it positive goes to get very attention-grabbing if SloClap does win, nonetheless .
If Sifu is a fighting game then MK11 is a turn-based RPG. Even although it sort of is.
MK11 being a turn-based RPG, that’s.
— Theo (@FGC_Theo) November 15, 2022
We’ll discover out which fighting game is voted the best of 2022 at The Game Awards subsequent month on December 8 the place we’re additionally prone to obtain extra large bulletins for upcoming titles like Tekken 8.
In my very own private view, I do not assume Sifu ought to have been included as a fighting game, however I can perceive the sentiment on this state of affairs. Let us know within the feedback in the event you assume single-player solely titles can nonetheless be fighting video games and whether or not Sifu suits into that class.
Should Sifu be considered a fighting game at #TheGameAwards ?
— Event Hubs (@eventhubs) November 17, 2022