Nintendo goes after fan-made custom Steam “icons” with DMCA takedowns

Enlarge / An archived web page displaying a few of the custom Steam imagery that has been taken down by Nintendo’s DMCA requests.

Nintendo has issued quite a few Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) requests in opposition to SteamGridDB (SGDB), a web site that hosts custom fan-made icons and pictures used to characterize video games on Steam’s front-end interface.

Since 2015, SGDB’s assortment has grown to incorporate tons of of hundreds of photographs representing tens of hundreds of titles. That consists of custom imagery for a lot of customary Steam video games and emulated sport ROMs, which will be added to Steam as “exterior video games.”

To be clear, SteamGridDB would not host the type of ROM recordsdata which have gotten different websites in authorized bother with Nintendo, and even the emulators used to run these video games. “We do not help piracy in any method,” an SGDB admin (who requested to stay nameless) instructed Ars. “The web site is only a free repository the place individuals can share choices to customise their sport launchers.”

But in a sequence of DMCA requests considered by Ars Technica, dated October 27, Nintendo says a few of the imagery on SGDB “shows Nintendo’s logos and different mental property (together with characters) which is prone to result in shopper confusion.” Thus, dozens of SGDB photographs have been changed with a clean picture that includes the textual content “this asset has been eliminated in response to a DMCA takedown request” (you may see a few of the particular photographs that had been eliminated on this Internet Archive snapshot from April and examine it to how the itemizing presently appears to be like).

It’s simply what Nintendoes

The SGDB admin stated they had been “not stunned in any respect” at Nintendo’s DMCA requests and added that they’ve “obtained some previously from different publishers and complied accordingly.” When pressed, although, the admin may consider solely a handful of different DMCA requests the positioning has acquired since its founding in 2015.

Thus far, Nintendo’s DMCA requests give attention to imagery for simply 5 Switch video games which might be listed on SGDB: Pokémon Scarlet & Violet, Splatoon 3, Super Mario Odyssey, The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wildand Xenoblade Chronicles 3. Other Switch video games listed on the positioning (some that includes the identical actual characters) are unaffected, as are photographs for a lot of older Nintendo titles.

The SGDB admin instructed Ars they’d “no stable thought” why Nintendo’s requests have been so focused. “I do not know what goes on of their authorized division.”

A page from SteamGridDB showing how the DMCAed images now appear (as well as one re-uploaded image with a cheeky transparent message overlayed on top).
Enlarge / A web page from SteamGridDB displaying how the DMCAed photographs now seem (in addition to one re-uploaded picture with a cheeky clear message overlayed on prime).

Even for the Switch video games in query, the DMCA requests centered on photographs that “straight up used sprites and belongings from [Nintendo’s] IP,” in response to the SGDB admin. Nintendo’s requests to date appear to have ignored “fully authentic creations” and “pure fan artwork” even when that artwork includes drawings of Nintendo’s authentic characters.

It’s unclear if these sorts of photographs would fall beneath a distinct authorized customary on this case. “If an IP holder asks to take down authentic creations then I’ll work out the easiest way to deal with that when it occurs,” the admin stated. “The web site is mainly all simply fan artwork, we’re open to publishers reaching out and discussing any points they could have. [The] the easiest way to discover a good plan of action is to debate choices.”

Nintendo’s SGDB takedowns come a couple of months after the corporate used comparable requests in opposition to YouTube movies explaining tips on how to set up Switch emulators on the Steam Deck. Before that, the corporate used DMCA requests on every little thing from fan video games to fashionable Game & Watch hacking movies to Mario-themed Minecraft movies.

“In the realm of firms ruthlessly working to manage their very own narrative to the detriment of analysis and reference, Nintendo ranks up there with Monsanto, coal firms, and the mob,” the Internet Archive’s Jason Scott instructed Ars again in 2018. “You anticipate feelings when individuals speak about previous video video games, however certainly one of them should not be afraid.”

Leave a Comment