Kyrie Irving is again, and here’s why history tells us that’s actually bad news for the Nets

Kyrie Irving has returned from suspension. Ben Simmons has mustered three consecutive video games that echo his previous excellence. And Kevin Durant continues to be Kevin Durant, a transcendent scoring machine averaging greater than 30 factors per sport who is lastly freed from the head coach he tried to pressure out over the summer season.

Throw in the likelihood to beat a battered Philadelphia 76ers group Tuesday evening — and choose up its third straight win for the first time this season — and good vibes are emanating from the Brooklyn Nets.

Don’t fall for any of it. This Nets group has nothing to supply however disappointment and drama.

Sure, the non permanent sense of positivity, a Brooklyn Nets specialty, will certainly unfold if Simmons has one other tremendous outing in his return to Philly. Or if Irving, having performed solely 26 minutes after coming back from an eight-game suspension for selling an antisemitic video, has a breakout efficiency.

Don’t get sucked in.

The phantasm could also be stronger, however the farce stays the identical: This talent-laden group is a timebomb — not a title contender. They’re all drama and no depth. They’re the sparkle with no actual likelihood at the bling.

Sure, as in all issues in sports activities, they might pull an upset. The Durant-Irving-Simmons trifecta would gel, in opposition to all odds and history, and see a regular-season parade of victories that offers technique to a playoff run worthy of all the hype that’s been churning in Brooklyn since Kyrie and KD teamed up.

But history, widespread sense and a slew of NBA league sources say what’s extra widespread is extra of the identical: Drama, the contender okay-dokey, and an inevitable grotesque meltdown that reminds us who they have been all alongside.

Star energy is a should for a championship run, however chemistry is the secret sauce that has to accompany it. That’s one in all the causes the Golden State Warriors, yr after yr, have dominated, with or with out Kevin Durant: That locker room is filled with actual leaders, and actual perception, and actual togetherness — or at the very least it was till Draymond Green punched teammate Jordan Poole in the face earlier this season.

This latest Los Angeles Lakers group tells the different facet of the coin — expertise with out togetherness can flip into recrimination with out hope.

But LeBron James, Russell Westbrook and Anthony Davis are a TED Talk on camaraderie and chemistry in comparison with this Nets squad.

Start with Irving, whose basketball presence in Brooklyn up to now has fallen method wanting expectations. Irving is massively gifted in the excessive. But exterior of enjoying with LeBron in LeBron’s prime — a significant asterisk — Irving has been a perennial unfavourable for virtually each single group he is been on. Literally.

This season, the Brooklyn Nets are 3-6 with their star level guard — and 5-3 with out him.

It might sound like a statistical anomaly pulled from a stupidly small pattern measurement, however dig slightly deeper. Look at the info, and the lack of influence he is had in his time away from LeBron.

In the six seasons, together with this one, since Kyrie Irving compelled his method out of the Cleveland Cavaliers, his group has been higher by profitable proportion with him on the ground versus with out him in solely a single season.


And that was 5 years in the past, in his first season in Boston.

The cold-hard comps on Kyrie’s groups in the common season with him versus with out him are putting:

So here’s the scorecard wanting again on the earlier 5 seasons: He improved his group as soon as. There was one other, by profitable proportion, that was a useless warmth. And then there have been three by which he was an albatross to success.

The bad instances have been extra widespread of late. In three of the final 4 seasons, Kyrie’s presence on the ground turned his group right into a sub-.500 squad. That’s a pattern measurement of 83 video games over three seasons — mainly a whole common season — by which Kyrie turns group right into a loser.

So, no, Kyrie’s drama, greatest and ugliest personified by the newest self-inflicted saga, is not the price of his greatness. It’s perception into the price his supposed-greatness inflicts on his groups.

And simply Kyrie.

Take Simmons, who — and there is no technique to put this kindly — instills the least quantity of confidence come large moments of any participant maybe in NBA history. The passed-up dunk in the playoffs, and his then-head coach Doc Rivers throwing him underneath the bus afterwards, might properly have damaged him.

Yes, he is performed properly the previous few video games, and we must always all hope he thrives and proves doubters like me flawed. No participant deserves to have a profession ruined by no matter mixture of bodily and psychological accidents which have led him so far. But life is not truthful, as others like Markelle Fultz can attest.

If a giant a part of your plan for NBA success is counting on Ben Simmons — in large video games no much less, when the stress ratchets up and his recollections and frailties should really feel 1,000 instances bigger — that plan is in large hassle.

The individual requested to shepherd this feast of fretfulness is Jacque Vaughn, who has three issues working in opposition to him: His profession report of 71-165. He’s by no means received greater than 23 video games in a single season. And the indisputable fact that he was clearly Durant’s accepted, second-choice candidate after the Nets backed away from hiring the suspended Boston Celtics head coach Ime Udoka.

That’s not a shot at Vaughn. A Nobel Peace Prize winner may wrestle to deliver this group collectively. But it is exhausting to see a second-choice coach clearly endorsed by a single famous person discovering the secret to this disturbing cocktail of grievances, stress and letdowns.

Into all of this stress steps Durant, whose abilities are excessive even by historic requirements. But in the NBA we are likely to stare at stars, get blinded by what we see in them and have hassle specializing in the particulars that matter.

As with this Nets group as an entire, Durant is an enormous expertise who doesn’t have a monitor report — exterior of working with the loaded Warriors — of profitable NBA championships. It’s exhausting to see by means of his greatness, however Durant the star has shone so brightly we have missed his lack of a resume away from Stephen Curry & Co., a LeBron-like winner.

If final yr’s Golden State Warriors run did not persuade folks of this, it is exhausting to see what is going to, however: Curry was all the time the greatest and most vital participant on these Warriors groups. That all the time made KD the second-best participant on the two championship groups on which KD performed.

You know what disproves that? Winning with out Curry, simply as Curry profitable with out Durant proved his worth as a champion, an NBA Finals MVP, and an all-time nice in a position to carry a group all the method.

Durant has by no means achieved that. And with this Nets group — with Kyrie Irving as a teammate, with Ben Simmons as a key piece who’ll be referred to as upon in pressure-packed moments — he by no means will.

Leave a Comment